Best Overall for Men
Carhartt Yukon Extremes Fleece Vest
The wind-fighting Carhartt Yukon Extremes fleece vest tops our list as the best style overall thanks to an expansive size range and classic appeal. Made with abrasion-resistant material and a snuggly sherpa-lining for warmth on the coldest days, it layers like a dream over everything. Top your favorite tees on warmer days and then buttoned flannel shirts as the weather gets crisp. It’s thick enough to keep you warm, but thin enough to layer below bulky parkas on the most frigid days of the year.
We also love all the included safety features. Reflective details make it a workwear essential, plus inner and outer pockets store phones, tissues and work gloves with ease. Droptail hemming, easy machine washing and zippered built-in compartments prove that no detail was overlooked. This customer-favorite style comes in a classic black shade and both regular and long/tall sizes up to 3X.
Pros:
- Most versatile design overall thanks to worksite and day-to-day wearing
- Available in regular sizes small through 3XL
- Tall sizes large through 2XL
- Reflective details for added safety
- Durable zipper closure
- Plenty of pockets
- Zippered compartments
- Cozy sherpa and abrasion-resistant material combination
Cons:
- Only available in a classic black color, but what more do you really need?
Find more of the best heated vests and essential heated gear to keep yourself toasty and warm.
Best Overall for Women
Orvis R65 Sweater Fleece Vest
Recycled materials and gorgeous nature-inspired hues make this eco-friendly sweater-knit Orvis R65 fleece vest a top women’s pick. Wear it over tees for for a long walk, with women’s workwear when you’re getting your hands dirty or layered below a casual blazer for a sophisticated look. Cozy recycled sweater fleece keeps you warm, while rugged YKK zippers help divert make the most of post-consumer plastic. This fleece vest for women keeps landfills from and waterways from overflowing with garbage while helping you get all your jobs done.
We also love the expanded arm holes that leave plenty of room for movement and breathability. Two zip pockets add protection and warmth, while figure-flattering princess seams add style to this utilitarian essential.
Pros:
- Versatile and wide arm holes use makes it an overall winner for women of all lifestyles
- Warm, recycled poly material keeps landfills from overflowing
- Rugged zippers
- Zippered pockets
- Available in six nature-inspired colors
- Machine washable
- Modest price point
Cons:
- No plus-size offerings right now
Psst! Pair it with one of these belt bags for storing essentials on the go.
Best Budget-Friendly
Amazon Essentials Polar Fleece Vest
Choosing this Amazon Essentials Polar Fleece vest is a budget-friendly choice that serves you well on crisp days. It comes in dozens of neutral and bright colors at an affordable price that easily allows you to stock up with a few. The thinner format polyester layers well over and under other articles of clothing, and comes in both standard and recycled material options. We also love women’s version of the Amazon Essentials Polar Fleece vest, which layers nicely women’s work overalls and other durable wardrobe pieces.
“I like a fleece vest when I want the warmth, but I’m working around abrasive or messy material and don’t want to trash the sleeves,” explains verified Amazon purchaser, Dave S., who gives it a full five stars. “This fleece vest is a great as an insulating layer under a shell when a full jacket would be too much.”
Pros:
- Affordable price point around $25
- Available in dozens of colors
- Comes in both men’s and women’s styles
- Expanded size range fits XXS through 4XL (depending on the color)
- Durable full zipper design
- Zipped pockets
- Machine washable
- Regular or recycled polyester options
Cons:
- Low-frills option doesn’t offer reflective safety taping or multi-layer design
Pros:
- Four-way stretch material offers ultimate flexibility
- Athletic fit sits close to the body without restricting mobility
- Odor-controlling fibers keep you smelling fresh for longer
- Secure zipped chest pocket for essentials
- Modest price point
- Machine washable
- Regular and tall sizes through XXL
Cons:
- Only available in black
Best Eco-Friendly
Tentree EcoLoft Vest
Available in both men’s Tentree EcoLoft fleece vest styles and women’s versions, this versatile essential is an eco-friendly wonder we can’t stop raving about. Organic cotton combined with recycled materials keep this cool-weather piece Earth-friendly and soft against the body. The fabric offers a subtle stretch and a medium weight that’s ideal for heading outdoors on crisp days and layering beneath bulkier coats when the dog days of winter come barking. A zipped woven chest pocket adds utility and character.
Pros:
- Eco-friendly organic cotton and recycled plastics blend
- Natulon durable zippers
- Available in both men’s and women’s styles
- Neutral color offerings
- Designed with high-end fashion in mind, these pieces work just as well in the yard as they do on casual Fridays
- Machine washable
Cons:
- Standard sizes only, and we suggest sizing up
- Limited color range
Best Reviewed
L.L. Bean Classic Mountain Fleece Vest
Shoppers have loved the L.L. Bean classic mountain vest for years thanks to careful design, an expanded size range and an affordable price point. It comes in both men’s styles and more tailored women’s cuts to please every type of outdoors enthusiast. The women’s version comes in regular, petite and plus sizes. The men’s style comes in regular and tall sizes through 3XL, making this one of the most size-inclusive offerings for all sorts of body types.
The slightly fitted, mid-weight fleece material is perfect for yard work and DIY projects all season long. It’s brushed for softness and warmth, yet offers wider arm holes and breathable fabric to keep you refreshed. Wear it under a coat on cold days or as a top layer over your favorite Handyma’am Goods overalls when the weather is just a bit brisk.
Pros:
- Thousands of realuser reviews call this fleece vest “the best”
- Available in both men’s and women’s styles
- Most expansive size range we’ve seen of any vest style
- Plenty of colors to choose from
- Moderate price point
- Brushed texture
- Machine washable
Cons:
- On the lighter side in terms of thickness, though that makes it an excellent choice for winter layering
Shop smarter with our expert recommendations for tools, gear and money-saving deals on can’t miss DIY and home products. Sign up for the Stuff We Love newsletter.